Nancy Kelley is best known to Austen readers for the Brides of Pemberley books, a short Pride and Prejudice continuation sequence that begins with Darcy’s point of view and then moves outward to Georgiana Darcy and Kitty Bennet.
For this article, the main reading order focuses on Nancy Kelley the Austenesque author. Online catalogues also show other books under the same name, including a 2007 romantic suspense novel and a 2026 young-reader nonfiction biography. Because those listings are not consistently tied to the same author profile, they are separated instead of folded into the main Austen order.
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This article may contain affiliate links. If you click one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
The Order That Matters Most
Read the Brides of Pemberley books in sequence:
- His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel
- Loving Miss Darcy
- Against His Will
That is the only essential continuity order for Nancy Kelley’s Austen fiction. The anthology appearances can be read later.
Brides of Pemberley Books in Order
- His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel (2011): A Pride and Prejudice retelling from Fitzwilliam Darcy’s point of view, following his changing feelings for Elizabeth Bennet and his slow recognition of his own pride.
- Loving Miss Darcy (2013): Georgiana Darcy becomes the central figure after Darcy and Elizabeth’s marriage, with her fears after Wickham shaping how she views courtship and trust.
- Against His Will (2013): Kitty Bennet receives the main romantic focus, as Sebastian Montgomery’s unexpected inheritance and dangerous family mystery pull her into a new kind of Austen continuation.
Brides of Pemberley Box Set
- Brides of Pemberley Box Set (2013): A collected edition containing the three main Brides of Pemberley books, useful if you want the complete sequence in one volume.
Do not treat the box set as a fourth story. It is a bundle of the trilogy.
Recommended Reading Order
- His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel (2011): Start here because it retells the original Pride and Prejudice romance through Darcy’s perspective and establishes the emotional foundation for the later Pemberley stories.
- Loving Miss Darcy (2013): Read this next because it follows the household after Darcy and Elizabeth’s marriage and gives Georgiana her own romantic arc.
- Against His Will (2013): Read this third because Kitty’s story grows out of the social world and character development already present in Loving Miss Darcy.
- Brides of Pemberley Box Set (2013): Choose this instead of the individual books if you want a collected edition, not in addition to them.
This is also the best order for new readers. It preserves the move from Darcy and Elizabeth to Georgiana and then to Kitty.
Holidays with Jane Anthology Appearances
Nancy Kelley also appears in the modern Austen-inspired Holidays with Jane anthologies. These are multi-author collections, not direct continuations of Brides of Pemberley.
- Holidays with Jane: Summer of Love (2016): Includes Kelley’s “Castle of the Sea,” a modern Northanger Abbey adaptation set around a Caribbean cruise premise.
- Holidays with Jane: Thankful Hearts (2016): Includes Kelley’s “Second Time’s the Charm,” a modern Sense and Sensibility adaptation centered on Marianne, disappointment, and a second chance with Brandon.
- Holidays with Jane: Will You Be Mine? (2017): Includes Kelley’s “Cupid’s Secret,” a Valentine’s-themed modern Austen adaptation in the later Holidays with Jane line.
Read these anthologies after the main Brides of Pemberley books if you want more Nancy Kelley. They are optional because they use modern Austen adaptation structures and do not continue her Regency trilogy.
Possible Same-Name or Separate Listings
Some book databases place additional titles under Nancy Kelley. These should be handled carefully.
- The Edge of Forever (2007): A romantic suspense novel involving Jennifer Denton, a child, kidnapping, and a drug-cartel threat; some databases list it under Nancy Kelley, but its connection to the later Austenesque author profile is not consistently confirmed.
- The Courage of Two: Anne Hutchinson, Mary Dyer and the Fight for Freedom of Conscience in Early America (2026): A young-reader nonfiction biography about Anne Hutchinson and Mary Dyer; current listings identify the author as Nancy Kelley, but the author profile and subject area differ enough that it should be kept separate unless confirmed by the author or publisher as the same Nancy Kelley.
For a clean Austen reading-order page, do not place these in the main sequence.
Publication Order for the Austen-Focused Catalogue
- His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel (2011): Darcy’s side of Pride and Prejudice, written as the opening work in the Pemberley sequence.
- Loving Miss Darcy (2013): Georgiana’s post-Wickham romantic story, set after Darcy and Elizabeth are together.
- Against His Will (2013): Kitty Bennet’s continuation story, with romance and mystery tied to Sebastian Montgomery.
- Brides of Pemberley Box Set (2013): The collected trilogy, not a new installment.
- Holidays with Jane: Summer of Love (2016): A modern multi-author Austen anthology including Kelley’s Northanger Abbey adaptation.
- Holidays with Jane: Thankful Hearts (2016): A Thanksgiving-themed modern Austen anthology including Kelley’s Sense and Sensibility adaptation.
- Holidays with Jane: Will You Be Mine? (2017): A Valentine’s-themed modern Austen anthology including a Kelley contribution.
Chronological Order
For the Brides of Pemberley books, the chronological order is the same as the reading order:
- His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel (2011): Runs alongside the events of Pride and Prejudice from Darcy’s viewpoint.
- Loving Miss Darcy (2013): Follows Georgiana after the Darcy-Elizabeth marriage.
- Against His Will (2013): Continues the wider post-Pride and Prejudice world with Kitty Bennet’s story.
The anthology stories do not belong to this Regency timeline. They are modern Austen adaptations and should be treated separately.
Are Nancy Kelley’s Books Connected?
The Brides of Pemberley books are connected.
His Good Opinion reworks the original Pride and Prejudice romance from Darcy’s side. Loving Miss Darcy then moves into Georgiana Darcy’s future, and Against His Will follows Kitty Bennet in the same continuation world.
The Holidays with Jane stories are not connected to that trilogy. They are modern, multi-author Austen adaptations.
Do You Need to Read Pride and Prejudice First?
Yes. Kelley’s main books assume that you know Elizabeth Bennet, Fitzwilliam Darcy, Georgiana Darcy, Kitty Bennet, Wickham, and the original marriage plot.
His Good Opinion can technically be read as Darcy’s version of the familiar story, but it works best when the reader already knows Austen’s original.
Latest Release Status
For Nancy Kelley’s Austenesque fiction, the latest confirmed original material found in current listings is her 2017 Holidays with Jane anthology appearance.
No newer confirmed Austenesque novel or Brides of Pemberley continuation was found during this check.
A 2026 nonfiction book titled The Courage of Two is listed under the name Nancy Kelley, but it should not be added to the Austen-fiction reading order without confirmed author-identity matching.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the first Nancy Kelley Austen book?
His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel is the first Nancy Kelley Austenesque book and the first Brides of Pemberley title.
What Nancy Kelley book should I read first?
Start with His Good Opinion. It sets up Kelley’s version of Darcy and leads naturally into the later Pemberley stories.
Is Brides of Pemberley a trilogy?
Yes. The main sequence is His Good Opinion, Loving Miss Darcy, and Against His Will.
Is the Brides of Pemberley Box Set a separate book?
No. It is a collected edition of the three Brides of Pemberley books.
Do I need to read Loving Miss Darcy before Against His Will?
Yes, that is the better order. Against His Will works better after Loving Miss Darcy because it continues the wider post-Pride and Prejudice social world.
Are the Holidays with Jane books required?
No. They are optional multi-author anthologies and do not continue the Brides of Pemberley trilogy.
Is His Good Opinion a Pride and Prejudice variation?
It is closer to a companion retelling. It follows Pride and Prejudice from Darcy’s point of view rather than creating a completely separate alternate plot.
Is The Edge of Forever part of Brides of Pemberley?
No. It is not part of the Brides of Pemberley series.
Is The Courage of Two part of Nancy Kelley’s Austen catalogue?
No. It is a 2026 young-reader nonfiction biography listed under the name Nancy Kelley, but it is not Austenesque fiction and should be kept separate from the Austen reading order.
Conclusion
Begin Nancy Kelley with His Good Opinion: A Mr. Darcy Novel, then read Loving Miss Darcy and Against His Will. That gives you the complete Brides of Pemberley sequence in the right order.
After the trilogy, add the Holidays with Jane anthologies only if you want Kelley’s modern Austen short fiction. Keep same-name or uncertain listings outside the main order unless a publisher or author source clearly confirms they belong to the same Nancy Kelley.
Frank is the editor of BookSeries.blog, focusing on publication order, chronological timelines, and spoiler-free reading guides for book series and fictional universes.