Heather Blake Books in Order (Updated April 28, 2026)

Heather Blake is the cozy paranormal mystery pen name of Heather Webber.

Under the Heather Blake name, she wrote two series: Wishcraft Mysteries and Magic Potion Mysteries. Both series feature witches, amateur sleuthing, small-town settings, and murder cases with light paranormal elements.

The two series are separate. You do not need to read Wishcraft before Magic Potion, or Magic Potion before Wishcraft.

The Short Version

• Begin with It Takes a Witch if you want Heather Blake’s longer and best-known series.
• Begin with A Potion to Die For if you want a shorter three-book series with a Southern potion-shop setting.

Read each series in order. The mysteries are usually case-based, but the character relationships and magical settings build from book to book.

Heather Blake Books in Publication Order

1. It Takes a Witch (2012): Darcy Merriweather arrives in Salem’s Enchanted Village and learns she comes from a line of Wishcrafters, just as a murder forces her into her first magical investigation.
2. A Witch Before Dying (2012): Darcy’s new role in the Enchanted Village deepens when another death pulls her into secrets tied to magic, family, and local history.
3. The Good, the Bad, and the Witchy (2013): Darcy becomes more settled as the village’s Wishcrafter, but a new murder proves that magical talent does not make small-town danger easier to untangle.
4. A Potion to Die For (2013): Carly Bell Hartwell’s potion shop becomes a crime scene when a man dies with one of her potion bottles in hand, making her the chief suspect in Hitching Post, Alabama.
5. The Goodbye Witch (2014): Darcy’s personal life and magical responsibilities collide when an Enchanted Village case threatens people close to her.
6. One Potion in the Grave (2014): Carly’s past and present collide when an old friend returns to Hitching Post and is murdered before she can settle a score.
7. Some Like It Witchy (2015): Darcy faces another Enchanted Village mystery as wishcraft, property, secrets, and murder twist together.
8. Ghost of a Potion (2015): Carly’s Halloween turns deadly when a man is murdered at a party and a ghostly complication gives the case a supernatural edge.
9. Gone With the Witch (2016): Darcy is tested again when murder disrupts the magical community and forces her to weigh suspicion against trust.
10. The Witch and the Dead (2016): Darcy’s life in Salem grows more complicated when the past refuses to stay buried and another investigation touches the supernatural side of the village.
11. To Catch a Witch (2018): Darcy faces a later-stage Wishcraft mystery where established relationships, village politics, and magical rules all matter.
12. A Witch to Remember (2019): The final published Wishcraft book brings Darcy into a mystery where secrets, memory, and trust shape the case.

Wishcraft Mysteries in Order

The Wishcraft Mysteries are set in the Enchanted Village section of Salem, Massachusetts. The series follows Darcy Merriweather, a Wishcrafter who can grant wishes and who repeatedly becomes involved in murder investigations.

This is the best Heather Blake series to start with if you want the fullest picture of her cozy paranormal mystery style.

1. It Takes a Witch (2012): Darcy Merriweather discovers her Wishcrafter heritage and is pulled into a murder case soon after arriving in the Enchanted Village.
2. A Witch Before Dying (2012): Darcy’s second case expands the magical community around her and shows that Salem’s secrets are not limited to one crime.
3. The Good, the Bad, and the Witchy (2013): Darcy’s role as a magical problem-solver grows as another murder exposes hidden motives in the village.
4. The Goodbye Witch (2014): The series becomes more personal for Darcy as the case reaches into relationships and emotional history.
5. Some Like It Witchy (2015): A new village mystery gives Darcy another test of her wishcraft, judgment, and trust in the people around her.
6. Gone With the Witch (2016): Darcy’s magical and investigative responsibilities continue to sharpen as another death unsettles the Enchanted Village.
7. The Witch and the Dead (2016): The series leans further into buried secrets, supernatural unease, and the danger of old stories returning.
8. To Catch a Witch (2018): Darcy’s late-series case works best after the earlier books because the village, cast, and magical rules are already established.
9. A Witch to Remember (2019): The final published Wishcraft mystery gives the series its latest Darcy Merriweather case and should be read after the first eight books.

Magic Potion Mysteries in Order

The Magic Potion Mysteries are set in Hitching Post, Alabama, and follow Carly Bell Hartwell, owner of the Little Shop of Potions.

This is the better starting point if you want a shorter Heather Blake series.

1. A Potion to Die For (2013): Carly Bell Hartwell’s love-potion business turns dangerous when a dead man is found in her shop with one of her potion bottles.
2. One Potion in the Grave (2014): Carly investigates the murder of an old childhood friend whose return to town had already stirred up trouble.
3. Ghost of a Potion (2015): Carly’s Halloween mystery includes a murder, a local party, and ghosts who complicate the case she is trying to solve.

Recommended Heather Blake Reading Order

For most readers, the best route is to read the two series separately rather than mixing them by publication date.

Route 1: Best Full Heather Blake Order

1. It Takes a Witch (2012): Start here for Darcy, Wishcraft, and the Enchanted Village setting.
2. A Witch Before Dying (2012): Continue Darcy’s early development and the magical community.
3. The Good, the Bad, and the Witchy (2013): Read third because it builds naturally from the first two cases.
4. The Goodbye Witch (2014): Stay in order as the character relationships become more important.
5. Some Like It Witchy (2015): Continue the main Wishcraft sequence before the later books.
6. Gone With the Witch (2016): Read after the first five because the setting is now fully established.
7. The Witch and the Dead (2016): Continue into the later Wishcraft mysteries.
8. To Catch a Witch (2018): Read near the end of the sequence.
9. A Witch to Remember (2019): Finish the Wishcraft series here.
10. A Potion to Die For (2013): Move to the Magic Potion Mysteries after completing Wishcraft.
11. One Potion in the Grave (2014): Continue Carly’s Hitching Post story.
12. Ghost of a Potion (2015): Finish the shorter Magic Potion series.

Route 2: Shorter Starting Route

1. A Potion to Die For (2013): Start here if you want a three-book series before committing to the longer Wishcraft run.
2. One Potion in the Grave (2014): Continue Carly’s second murder case.
3. Ghost of a Potion (2015): Finish the Magic Potion Mysteries.
4. It Takes a Witch (2012): Begin the longer Wishcraft Mysteries after that.

Chronological Order

There is no confirmed shared internal chronology between the Wishcraft Mysteries and the Magic Potion Mysteries.

Within each series, publication order is the correct reading order. The cases are individual mysteries, but Darcy and Carly’s personal lives, town relationships, and magical roles develop across their books.

For a first read, do not rearrange the books chronologically. Read by series.

Heather Blake and Heather Webber

Heather Blake is a pen name used by Heather Webber.

The Heather Webber books are not part of the Heather Blake cozy paranormal mystery order. They include other mystery series, romantic mystery, magical realism novels, romance, and historical romance.

Keep them separate unless you are building a complete Heather Webber bibliography.

Latest Release Status

The latest published Heather Blake book is A Witch to Remember (2019).

The Wishcraft Mysteries currently contain nine books. The Magic Potion Mysteries currently contain three books.

There is no announcement for an upcoming book at the time of writing such as April 28, 2026.

FAQ

What Heather Blake book should I read first?

Read It Takes a Witch first if you want the main Heather Blake series. Read A Potion to Die For first if you want the shorter Magic Potion Mysteries.

Are the Wishcraft and Magic Potion books connected?

They are best treated as separate series. Both are cozy paranormal mysteries about witches, but they follow different heroines, towns, and magical setups.

Do Heather Blake’s books need to be read in order?

Yes, within each series. Each book has its own mystery, but the character relationships and setting details build over time.

Is Heather Blake the same person as Heather Webber?

Yes. Heather Blake is a pen name of Heather Webber. The Heather Webber books should be kept separate from the Heather Blake reading order unless you are reading the author’s full catalogue.

Is the Wishcraft series finished?

There has not been a new Wishcraft book since A Witch to Remember in 2019. The series currently stands at nine published books.

Is the Magic Potion series finished?

The Magic Potion Mysteries currently stand at three books, ending with Ghost of a Potion.

Conclusion

The easiest Heather Blake reading path is It Takes a Witch through A Witch to Remember, followed by A Potion to Die For through Ghost of a Potion.