Eden Butler writes emotionally intense contemporary romance, sports romance, romantic suspense, mafia romance, rock-star romance, and paranormal romance. Her best-known books include the Seeking Serenity series, the multigenerational Thin Love books, the Saints and Sinners football spin-off, and the Nailed Down series co-written with Chelle Bliss.
The catalog contains several traps for completionists. Some companion stories repeat events from another viewpoint, some collections combine previously published books, and one paranormal novel was revised and republished under a new title.
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This article may contain affiliate links. If you click one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
There is also an important current-status note. Eden Butler is no longer actively publishing contemporary romance under this name. Her existing backlist remains available, while her newer fantasy work is primarily published as Tee Tate. Tee Tate books belong to a separate author identity and are not included in this Eden Butler reading order.
The Books Most Likely to Be Misordered
Five placements deserve attention before looking at the full bibliography.
- Behind the Pitch: Read after Chasing Serenity. It retells part of the first book from Declan’s perspective and is not a prequel.
- My Beloved: Read after Thin Love. Its events occur before the Thin Love epilogue, but the novella assumes knowledge of the original novel.
- Last Love of Luka Hale: Do not use this as a first Eden Butler book. It is labeled as a Saints and Sinners prequel, but it contains major spoilers for Thin Love.
- Protocol: Read Against Protocol, Broken Protocol, and Final Protocol consecutively. They form one serial storyline.
- Forgotten Magic: This is the revised and traditionally published version of Crimson Cove. They should not be counted as two separate principal stories.
Seeking Serenity Books in Order
Seeking Serenity follows a close group of friends in the college town of Cavanagh, Tennessee. Each full-length novel changes the central couple, but the friendships, family problems, sports connections, and earlier relationships continue throughout the series.
The official current catalog lists four main novels. A companion novella, Behind the Pitch, belongs directly after book one.
1. Chasing Serenity
Chasing Serenity (2013): Graduate student Autumn McShane is recovering from the accident that killed her mother when an ill-advised bet forces her into an alliance with sarcastic Irish rugby player Declan Fraser.
This is the correct introduction to Cavanagh and the friendship group that supports the later couples.
Autumn and Declan’s romance includes grief, betrayal, rivalry, and secrets that should be discovered before reading Declan’s companion account.
1.5. Behind the Pitch
Behind the Pitch (2014): Declan Fraser gives his perspective on his complicated relationship with Autumn, revisiting events from Chasing Serenity through the thoughts and motives he did not reveal in the original novel.
This is an alternate-viewpoint companion, not a new couple’s story.
Placement: Read it after Chasing Serenity. Reading it first would weaken Autumn’s discoveries and expose Declan’s reasoning too early.
2. Finding Serenity
Finding Serenity (2014): Mollie Malone has built a new family among her college friends, but danger from her past returns while former Marine Vaughn Winchester keeps intruding on the life he insists he is too damaged to share.
The romance combines an age difference, suspense, family loyalty, and two characters carrying secrets they believe will protect the other person.
Previous Seeking Serenity characters remain active around Mollie and Vaughn.
3. Claiming Serenity
Claiming Serenity (2015): Layla Mullens and football player Donovan Donley conduct an escalating prank war in public while maintaining a private physical relationship neither wants to define.
Their arrangement becomes harder to control when genuine need replaces hostility, and Donovan’s connection to Layla’s father raises the professional stakes.
Read the first two main novels before this one for the full friendship-group context.
4. Catching Serenity
Catching Serenity (2016): Sayo McIntyre’s relationship with Quinn O’Malley develops through attraction, loss, recovery, and a bond that changes both of their lives.
This is the final full-length Seeking Serenity novel.
The book gathers the established friends around its central couple, so it carries more emotional weight after the earlier romances.
Recommended Seeking Serenity Order
- Chasing Serenity (2013): Autumn and Declan begin the Cavanagh continuity through an enemies-to-lovers rugby romance.
- Behind the Pitch (2014): Declan revisits the first romance from his own perspective.
- Finding Serenity (2014): Mollie and Vaughn face danger, secrets, and an age-gap attraction.
- Claiming Serenity (2015): Layla and Donovan turn a prank war and hidden arrangement into a serious relationship.
- Catching Serenity (2016): Sayo and Quinn lead the final full-length story.
The series is sometimes sold in Cavanagh omnibus volumes. Those collections repackage the same novels and companion material rather than adding new central romances.
Thin Love Books in Order
Thin Love begins with Kona Hale and Keira Riley, then shifts to younger characters connected to their family.
The three full-length novels form the stable main sequence. Several shorter pieces add material for established couples, but they are not all consistently offered as separate current editions.
1. Thin Love
Thin Love (2014): Keira Riley and football star Kona Hale reunite sixteen years after their destructive college relationship, forcing them to confront the betrayals, family interference, and hidden consequences that kept them apart.
The story moves between their younger relationship and their adult second chance.
This novel establishes the Hale family, the New Orleans Steamers, and the history later used by Saints and Sinners.
1.5. My Beloved
My Beloved (2014): Kona and Keira receive an additional chapter set before the epilogue of Thin Love, showing the couple during the period between the main resolution and the novel’s final glimpse of their future.
Although the events occur before the epilogue, the novella assumes that the reader already knows the entire original story.
Placement: Read after Thin Love.
2. Thick Love
Thick Love (2015): Ransom Riley Hale, the son of Kona and Keira, is a talented college football player whose privileged public image conceals grief, guilt, and a belief that he does not deserve Aly King’s love.
Aly offers the possibility of returning to life after tragedy, but Ransom fears that his darkness will destroy her as well.
Reading Thin Love first is important because Ransom’s family history and emotional environment begin there.
3. Thick & Thin
Thick & Thin (2016): Ransom faces the loss of Aly after the relationship he believed would last forever collapses, forcing him to confront whether love can survive broken trust and prolonged separation.
This book continues the central relationship from Thick Love rather than introducing an unrelated couple.
Required order: Read Thick Love immediately before Thick & Thin.
My Always
My Always (2018): This shorter Thin Love piece adds material connected to the established Hale-family relationships and is commonly positioned after the three full-length novels.
It has also appeared inside Thin Love bundles rather than as a consistently available independent edition.
Status: Optional bonus story.
Thick & Thin Thoughts
Thick & Thin Thoughts (2017): This supplementary release gathers material associated with the emotions, quotations, or creative presentation of the Thin Love world rather than functioning as another full-length central romance.
It should be treated as bonus content after the main series.
Status: Optional companion material.
The Cleanest Thin Love Order
- Thin Love
- My Beloved
- Thick Love
- Thick & Thin
- My Always, optional
- Thick & Thin Thoughts, optional companion
Readers using the Ohana Legacy or another Thin Love collection should check the contents before buying shorter pieces separately. Some bundles already include My Beloved and My Always.
Saints and Sinners Books in Order
Saints and Sinners is a football-romance spin-off set in the same universe as Thin Love. The series follows people connected to the New Orleans Steamers, including players, executives, and characters whose histories reach back into the Hale family.
The numbering creates a potential spoiler problem. Last Love of Luka Hale is called book one and functions as a prequel, but the author warns that it contains major spoilers for Thin Love.
For that reason, the recommended reader order differs from a simple chronological order.
1. Last Love of Luka Hale
Last Love of Luka Hale (2019): Gia Jilani returns to the place where her childhood love for Luka Hale ended in pain, forcing her to confront memories that have shaped every relationship and decision since.
The novel is set earlier within the Thin Love timeline and supplies crucial history for Gia.
Spoiler warning: Read Thin Love before this book. Starting with Luka’s story reveals information that the first Thin Love novel is designed to uncover gradually.
2. Roughing the Kicker
Roughing the Kicker (2018): Reese Noble earns a place as the New Orleans Steamers’ female kicker and must prove she belongs while working with quarterback Ryder Glenn, the man who broke her heart ten years earlier.
The romance combines professional sports pressure, public scrutiny, and a second chance between former lovers.
This is the easiest independent entry into Saints and Sinners for readers who have already completed Thin Love.
3. Offsides
Offsides (2019): Gia Jilani has become the NFL’s first female general manager when her attraction to linebacker Kai Pukui forces her to reconsider the rules she uses to protect herself.
Kai’s familiarity connects their developing relationship to Gia’s earlier loss.
Read Last Love of Luka Hale before Offsides for the complete emotional history behind Gia’s decisions.
Recommended Thin Love and Saints and Sinners Route
- Thin Love
- My Beloved
- Thick Love
- Thick & Thin
- Last Love of Luka Hale
- Roughing the Kicker
- Offsides
This order preserves the major Thin Love revelations while keeping Gia’s earlier and later stories in a meaningful sequence.
God of Rock Duet in Order
The God of Rock duet follows Dash Justice and Iris Dane across two books. These are not connected standalones.
The conflict begins in Kneel and continues directly into Beg.
1. Kneel
Kneel (2017): Dash Justice is a famous songwriter and rock star, but Iris remembers him as Jamie, the boy she loved before his cruel words turned their relationship into resentment.
When his career and her anger bring them together again, Iris is determined not to accept weak excuses for the humiliation he caused.
The first book opens their friends-to-enemies conflict and does not provide the complete relationship resolution.
2. Beg
Beg (2018): Dash accepts that pride, denial, and a deliberate insult destroyed his future with Iris, leaving him willing to apologize and fight for the relationship he once rejected.
This is a direct continuation of Kneel.
Required order: Read the two books consecutively.
Midnight Soul
Midnight Soul (2018): Dash and Iris receive additional material connected to the God of Rock relationship after the principal duet.
The exact presentation has varied by edition and catalog, so it is safest to treat this as supplemental couple content rather than a separate third main novel.
Status: Optional follow-up.
Nailed Down Books in Order
Nailed Down is co-written by Eden Butler and Chelle Bliss. The four books move from television and home renovation into military romance and the Carelli criminal family.
Each installment has a different central couple, but the people and family connections overlap.
1. Nailed Down
Nailed Down (2018): Television handyman Kane and his best friend and co-worker Kit Carlyle begin completing the adventurous bucket list left by her late cousin, turning years of hidden attraction into a relationship neither can dismiss.
The book introduces the wider circle used throughout the series.
It is primarily a friends-to-lovers romance, despite the more dangerous direction taken by later books.
2. Tied Down
Tied Down (2019): Cara Carelli draws her ex-husband into a dangerous situation, reopening a relationship built on manipulation, attraction, family loyalty, and unresolved love.
This book introduces the Carelli family more directly.
Read it before the separate Carelli Family Saga because the family and its conflicts are established here.
3. Kneel Down
Kneel Down (2019): A wounded former SEAL returns determined to claim his best friend Gin Sullivan after injury and missed timing prevent him from admitting what she has meant to him.
The romance combines military recovery with a friendship that has remained unresolved for years.
Characters from the earlier Nailed Down books continue around the couple.
4. Stripped Down
Stripped Down (2019): A man raised within a criminal family seeks redemption and a second chance with Sammy, the woman he believes represents the only goodness he has ever known.
Danger surrounding the Carellis makes the personal reconciliation part of a larger family conflict.
This book is the strongest bridge from Nailed Down into the Carelli Family Saga.
Carelli Family Saga Books in Order
The Carelli Family Saga expands the mafia family introduced through Tied Down and Stripped Down. Readers can begin with Smoke, but reading Nailed Down first provides fuller background on Cara, the family structure, and earlier criminal conflicts.
1. Smoke
Smoke (2020): Smoke Carelli avoids commitment until Maggie Ramirez and her child disrupt every rule he has made for his life, while danger from Maggie’s past threatens the family he is beginning to want.
The book establishes Cuoricino, New York, and the Carelli family’s attempt to impose order on its criminal world.
Smoke and Maggie’s story combines friends-to-lovers development, single parenthood, and mafia suspense.
2. Dario
Dario (2021): Dario Carelli is assigned to force new bakery owner Ava Anderson to follow the town’s rules, but her defiance and visible fear reveal that she is running from something more dangerous than his family.
Dario’s own history includes prison and sacrifices made for the Carellis.
The novel continues the conflict introduced in Smoke and should not be treated as an unrelated mafia romance.
3. Dante
Dante (2023): Dante Carelli returns after years in Italy hoping to atone for a deal that cost his brother’s freedom, his family’s trust, and his relationship with hacker Kat Harrell.
Dante and Kat must work together against the family’s enemies even though she has no reason to trust his promises.
This book resolves major Carelli conflicts prepared in the first two novels.
Best Carelli Reading Path
For the fullest family continuity, use:
- Nailed Down
- Tied Down
- Kneel Down
- Stripped Down
- Smoke
- Dario
- Dante
Readers interested only in the concentrated mafia saga may begin with Smoke and continue through Dante.
Protocol Books in Order
Protocol is a three-part romantic-suspense serial. All three installments follow the same central storyline and must be read in order.
The series is not currently highlighted on Eden Butler’s main bibliography page, but it remains part of her published backlist.
1. Against Protocol
Against Protocol (2018): Cruz and Lia are pulled back into a relationship shaped by shared history, secrecy, danger, and information that neither can safely ignore.
The short first installment establishes the romantic-suspense conflict and ends without a complete resolution.
Do not treat it as a standalone novella.
2. Broken Protocol
Broken Protocol (2018): Cruz and Lia face the immediate consequences of the first installment as the danger surrounding them expands and the rules meant to protect them begin to fail.
This book starts directly after Against Protocol.
Reading it independently would leave essential relationship and plot information unexplained.
3. Final Protocol
Final Protocol (2018): The serial reaches its conclusion as Cruz and Lia confront the final threat, the truths behind their separation, and the cost of securing a future together.
The book completes both the romantic and suspense arcs.
Secret Service Collection
Secret Service (2019): This bundle contains Against Protocol, Broken Protocol, and Final Protocol in one edition.
It is an omnibus, not a fourth Protocol story.
Forgotten Magic and Crimson Cove
The paranormal title in Eden Butler’s backlist requires a duplicate-edition warning.
Crimson Cove
Crimson Cove (2015): Janiver Benoit returns to the magical community she fled and must work with Bane Illes, the silent wizard connected to the kiss and secrets she left behind.
This was the original self-published version of the story.
Forgotten Magic
Forgotten Magic (2020): Janiver is called back to Crimson Cove after an artifact that conceals magic from mortals is stolen, forcing her to work with Bane while betrayal and supernatural danger close around them.
This is the revised and republished version of Crimson Cove.
Buying rule: Choose Forgotten Magic for the updated edition. Do not count the two titles as separate novels in a reading challenge.
The book has sometimes been labeled as the opening of a Crimson Cove series, but no second published installment is reliably established in the current Eden Butler catalog.
Other Eden Butler Standalone Novels
These books do not require one of the principal series.
Shadows and Lies
Shadows and Lies (2015): Former Navy SEAL and investigator Neil Ryan receives information that revives questions about his mother’s death, drawing him into a romantic-suspense mystery where buried secrets challenge his ideas about justice.
The book was labeled as the first Shadows novel.
No completed second installment is consistently confirmed, so it should be approached as the only published entry rather than the beginning of a complete multi-book arc.
Infinite Us
Infinite Us (2017): Technology-focused Nash Nation meets his new neighbor Willow O’Bryant and begins experiencing dreams that feel like memories of another couple, another era, and a love interrupted by secrets.
The novel combines contemporary romance with reincarnation, memory, and magical realism.
It stands outside Seeking Serenity and Thin Love.
Fall
Fall (2017): Lily Campbell returns toward the island home and first love she left behind after tragedy and a collapsing career force her to confront the promises and lies of her past.
Keilen Rivers represents the life Lily could have chosen before responsibility and loss drove her away.
This is a standalone second-chance romance.
Fearless Rebel
Fearless Rebel (2021): Ed Mescal’s reputation as cold and fearless is challenged by Piper Warren, the woman connected to the person he was beneath the identity others placed on him.
The novel belongs to the multi-author Hero Club project.
It can be read independently without completing another Eden Butler series.
Shorter Works and Anthology Contributions
Some earlier releases are not consistently featured in the current official catalog. Their placement is therefore best handled cautiously.
Platform Four
Platform Four (2016): A historical romance unfolds against the approach of war, using a railway platform, separation, and the uncertainty of return to test a relationship interrupted by events larger than the couple.
It was published within the multi-author Legacy Falls world.
Status: Separate shared-world novella.
Santa Baby
Santa Baby (2019): A shorter holiday romance uses Christmas expectations and an unexpected connection to create a self-contained seasonal story.
It is not required for Seeking Serenity, Thin Love, or Saints and Sinners.
Status: Optional holiday novella.
I’ve Seen You Naked and Didn’t Laugh
I’ve Seen You Naked and Didn’t Laugh (2016): This independently listed contemporary title centers on the vulnerability created when familiarity, embarrassment, and attraction disrupt an established relationship.
Current official catalog information is limited, so it should be treated as a separate backlist work rather than assigned to a named series without stronger confirmation.
Night Shift
Night Shift (2015): This multi-author collection includes romance stories from several writers, including Eden Butler material.
The collection is optional and should not be counted as another numbered Eden Butler series novel.
A Book A Day Presents: Color Theory
A Book A Day Presents: Color Theory (2021): This collection or collaborative project includes work associated with several authors rather than introducing a new Eden Butler continuity.
Status: Optional anthology or collection.
Complete Eden Butler Series List
The stable named series are:
Seeking Serenity
- Chasing Serenity
- Behind the Pitch
- Finding Serenity
- Claiming Serenity
- Catching Serenity
Thin Love
- Thin Love
- My Beloved
- Thick Love
- Thick & Thin
- My Always, optional
- Thick & Thin Thoughts, optional
Saints and Sinners
- Last Love of Luka Hale
- Roughing the Kicker
- Offsides
Read Thin Love before all three.
God of Rock
- Kneel
- Beg
- Midnight Soul, optional follow-up
Nailed Down
- Nailed Down
- Tied Down
- Kneel Down
- Stripped Down
Carelli Family Saga
- Smoke
- Dario
- Dante
Protocol
- Against Protocol
- Broken Protocol
- Final Protocol
Crimson Cove
- Forgotten Magic
Crimson Cove is the earlier version of the same book.
Shadows
- Shadows and Lies
No second published installment is reliably confirmed.
Chronological Order Versus Publication Order
A single chronological list is not useful across the entire bibliography. Seeking Serenity, Thin Love, the Carellis, God of Rock, Protocol, and the paranormal books occupy different continuities.
Two local timeline questions do matter.
Thin Love and Last Love of Luka Hale
Last Love of Luka Hale takes place earlier in the shared timeline, but it should not be read before Thin Love. The prequel contains major revelations about people and events introduced in the original novel.
Publication-sensitive order is better:
- Thin Love
- My Beloved
- Thick Love
- Thick & Thin
- Last Love of Luka Hale
- Roughing the Kicker
- Offsides
Crimson Cove and Forgotten Magic
These are not two timeline entries.
Forgotten Magic replaces the earlier version for most new readers.
Complete Publication Order
The following list tracks the principal original releases and clearly identified shorter works. Collections are excluded when they only repackage existing stories.
- Chasing Serenity (2013): Autumn and Declan open the Cavanagh friendship group through grief, rugby, rivalry, and reluctant trust.
- Behind the Pitch (2014): Declan revisits the opening romance from his perspective.
- Finding Serenity (2014): Mollie and former Marine Vaughn face danger from her past and secrets from his.
- Thin Love (2014): Kona and Keira confront the damage left by their college relationship sixteen years earlier.
- My Beloved (2014): Kona and Keira receive an additional story set before the original epilogue.
- Claiming Serenity (2015): Layla and Donovan’s prank war hides a relationship neither wants to define.
- Shadows and Lies (2015): Investigator Neil Ryan reopens questions surrounding his mother’s death.
- Thick Love (2015): Ransom Hale’s grief and guilt threaten his relationship with Aly.
- Crimson Cove (2015): The original version of Janiver and Bane’s paranormal romance appears.
- Catching Serenity (2016): Sayo and Quinn close the full-length Cavanagh sequence.
- Thick & Thin (2016): Ransom fights for another chance after Aly leaves their shared life.
- Platform Four (2016): A historical relationship faces separation and the approach of war.
- I’ve Seen You Naked and Didn’t Laugh (2016): Familiarity and vulnerability complicate an independent contemporary relationship.
- Infinite Us (2017): Nash and Willow encounter memories of another love through dreams and possible reincarnation.
- Fall (2017): Lily returns toward the island and man she left after her life begins to collapse.
- Kneel (2017): Iris confronts the rock star who was once the boy she loved.
- Thick & Thin Thoughts (2017): Supplementary material revisits the emotions and presentation of the Thin Love world.
- Beg (2018): Dash attempts to repair the damage he caused in Kneel.
- My Always (2018): A shorter Thin Love piece adds material for the established family.
- Nailed Down (2018): Best friends Kane and Kit turn a bucket list into a relationship.
- Roughing the Kicker (2018): Reese fights for her NFL career while facing former love Ryder.
- Against Protocol (2018): Cruz and Lia begin a dangerous romantic-suspense serial.
- Broken Protocol (2018): The couple faces the immediate consequences of the first Protocol installment.
- Final Protocol (2018): Cruz and Lia’s suspense story reaches its conclusion.
- Midnight Soul (2018): Additional God of Rock material returns to Dash and Iris.
- Tied Down (2019): Cara Carelli and her ex-husband reopen a dangerous and unresolved marriage.
- Kneel Down (2019): A wounded former SEAL returns determined to claim his best friend.
- Stripped Down (2019): A Carelli-connected hero seeks redemption and another chance with Sammy.
- Last Love of Luka Hale (2019): Gia confronts the childhood relationship and loss behind her adult defenses.
- Offsides (2019): General manager Gia becomes involved with linebacker Kai.
- Santa Baby (2019): A self-contained Christmas romance adds optional seasonal reading.
- Forgotten Magic (2020): The revised version of Crimson Cove returns Janiver to Bane and a threatened magical community.
- Smoke (2020): Maggie and her child disrupt Smoke Carelli’s rejection of love and permanence.
- Dario (2021): Dario confronts bakery owner Ava and the danger she is hiding.
- Fearless Rebel (2021): Ed and Piper lead an independent Hero Club romance.
- Dante (2023): Dante returns to repair his family and his broken relationship with Kat.
Same-year order may vary slightly by edition. Series order is more important than the exact interleaving of unrelated releases.
Recommended Reading Routes
The Best First Eden Butler Series
Read Seeking Serenity:
- Chasing Serenity
- Behind the Pitch
- Finding Serenity
- Claiming Serenity
- Catching Serenity
This route introduces Eden Butler’s emotional, character-driven contemporary style without requiring knowledge of another continuity.
The Complete Football Family Route
- Thin Love
- My Beloved
- Thick Love
- Thick & Thin
- Last Love of Luka Hale
- Roughing the Kicker
- Offsides
This is the most important shared-universe order because it protects major spoilers.
The Carelli Route
- Nailed Down
- Tied Down
- Kneel Down
- Stripped Down
- Smoke
- Dario
- Dante
The first Nailed Down book is lighter than the later mafia material, but it establishes the connected group before the Carelli conflict becomes central.
The Short Continuous Stories
For readers who prefer one couple or plot without changing protagonists:
- Kneel, then Beg
- Against Protocol, then Broken Protocol, then Final Protocol
- Thick Love, then Thick & Thin
These sequences should not be interrupted or reversed.
The Paranormal Starting Point
Forgotten Magic (2020): Janiver returns to Crimson Cove to recover a stolen magical artifact while confronting Bane, the wizard she loved and left.
No contemporary Eden Butler book is required.
Choose this edition rather than buying both Forgotten Magic and Crimson Cove.
Latest Eden Butler Book and Current Status
The latest confirmed original full-length Eden Butler novel is Dante, published in 2023.
Dante (2023): Dante Carelli returns from exile seeking redemption and Kat’s help against the enemies threatening his family, completing the current Carelli Family Saga.
No later Eden Butler contemporary-romance release is officially scheduled as of August 4, 2026.
The author’s current biography states that she is no longer actively writing contemporary romance under the Eden Butler name. Her backlist remains available, with some books receiving updated covers or editions.
Her current fantasy work as Tee Tate should be treated as a separate bibliography.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was Eden Butler’s first book?
Chasing Serenity (2013): Autumn McShane and rugby player Declan Fraser form a reluctant alliance while grief, an ex-boyfriend, and an escalating bet complicate their attraction.
It is the first Seeking Serenity novel and the earliest principal release in her established bibliography.
What is the best Eden Butler book to start with?
Chasing Serenity is the best general starting point.
Readers interested specifically in intense football romance can begin with Thin Love. Paranormal-romance readers can begin independently with Forgotten Magic.
Do the Seeking Serenity books need to be read in order?
Yes, publication order is recommended.
Each full-length novel follows a different couple, but the friends remain closely connected and later books reveal earlier relationship outcomes.
Should Behind the Pitch be read before Chasing Serenity?
No.
Behind the Pitch revisits the first book from Declan’s perspective and reveals thoughts Autumn does not initially understand. Read it after Chasing Serenity.
Do Thin Love and Thick Love follow the same couple?
No.
Thin Love follows Kona and Keira. Thick Love shifts to their son Ransom and Aly.
Family history makes Thin Love required background for Ransom’s story.
Does Thick & Thin continue Thick Love?
Yes.
Both books follow Ransom and Aly. Read them consecutively and in order.
Where does My Beloved fit?
Read My Beloved after Thin Love.
Its story takes place before the original novel’s epilogue, but it assumes that the reader already knows Kona and Keira’s full history.
Should Last Love of Luka Hale be read first?
No.
Although it is a prequel within the shared timeline, the author warns that it contains major spoilers for Thin Love. Read Thin Love before Luka’s book.
Are Saints and Sinners and Thin Love connected?
Yes.
Saints and Sinners is a football spin-off in the same universe. The New Orleans Steamers, the Hale family, and Gia’s history create direct links.
Is God of Rock a duet?
Yes.
Kneel begins Dash and Iris’s relationship conflict. Beg completes it.
Are the Nailed Down books co-written?
Yes.
Eden Butler wrote the four Nailed Down books with Chelle Bliss.
Is the Carelli Family Saga connected to Nailed Down?
Yes.
Carelli family members and criminal conflicts appear in Nailed Down before Smoke opens the dedicated family saga.
Must the Protocol books be read together?
Yes.
Against Protocol, Broken Protocol, and Final Protocol form one serial romance and suspense plot. The collection Secret Service packages all three.
Are Crimson Cove and Forgotten Magic different books?
They are versions of the same central paranormal story.
Forgotten Magic is the revised and republished edition. New readers should choose that version and avoid counting both titles.
Is Shadows and Lies part of a completed series?
It was labeled as Shadows book one, but no second published book is reliably confirmed.
Readers should approach it as the only available installment.
What are the Cavanagh collections?
The Cavanagh volumes collect Seeking Serenity books and companion material.
They are omnibus editions rather than additional romances.
Does Eden Butler still publish romance?
Her current biography states that she is no longer actively writing contemporary romance under the Eden Butler name.
She now writes primarily as Tee Tate, focusing on fantasy and related genres.
What is Eden Butler’s latest book?
The latest confirmed original full-length novel is Dante, published in 2023.
It is the third Carelli Family Saga book.
Conclusion
Eden Butler’s safest starting point is Chasing Serenity, followed by Behind the Pitch and the remaining Seeking Serenity novels.
Readers choosing the football continuity should begin with Thin Love and delay Last Love of Luka Hale until afterward, despite its prequel status. Readers following the Carelli family should complete Nailed Down before moving into Smoke, Dario, and Dante.
The central rule is to preserve revelations rather than follow chronology blindly. Read companion viewpoints after their original novels, keep true duets and serials together, and treat revised editions and omnibus collections as alternate forms rather than new books.
Frank is the editor of BookSeries.blog, focusing on publication order, chronological timelines, and spoiler-free reading guides for book series and fictional universes.